Showing posts with label Nobel prize. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nobel prize. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 12, 2013

David J. Wineland: trapping ions for clocks and computers

Simon Thwaite recently completed a D.Phil. in Atomic & Laser Physics at the University of Oxford, and is currently a postdoctoral researcher at the Ludwig Maximilian University in Munich. The first part of his post series commenting on the 2012 Nobel Prize in Physics can be found here.

In this post he gives an overview of the field of trapped ions, describes two of its most important applications, and describes what goes on behind the scenes when a trapped ion interacts with a laser beam.


David J. Wineland – probing trapped atoms with light



David Wineland, an experimental physicist at the National Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST) in Boulder, Colorado, is one of the leading researchers in the field of trapped ions: that is, the study of how positively-charged ions (i.e. atoms stripped of one or more electrons) may be trapped, cooled, and manipulated.  This field shares many similarities with experiments on neutral atoms (laser cooling, for example, is just as useful for ions as it is for neutral atoms), but also has a number of significant differences. The most important difference that distinguishes ions from atoms is, obviously enough, the fact that ions have a non-zero net electrical charge. This has two very important consequences.

Trapped ions: trapping and interactions

A string of trapped ions (red dots) lined up in a Paul trap
can be imaged with a tightly-focused laser beam and CCD camera.

Image credit: Rainer Blatt experimental group, University of Innsbruck.

Applying an electric field to an ion produces a force on the ion: positive ions are drawn in the direction of the field. [In contrast, applying an electric field to a neutral atom changes the ‘shape’ of the atom slightly, since the positively-charged nucleus and negatively-charged electron cloud are drawn in opposite directions, but produces no net force.] Consequently, whereas traps for neutral atoms must rely on combinations of laser light and magnetic fields, ions can be trapped just by electric fields. Most of the recent trapped-ion experiments use some variation on the Paul trap (a.k.a. the quadrupole ion trap) which uses a combination of static (DC) and oscillating (AC) electric fields to trap ions along a 1-dimensional line.

Tuesday, October 30, 2012

The 2012 Nobel Prize in Physics: The background

[The following is a guest post from Simon Thwaite. Simon recently completed his doctorate in the subdepartment of Atomic & Laser Physics at the University of Oxford. He is currently in the limbo that lies between the submission of a doctoral thesis and its examination, and is looking forward to taking up a postdoctoral research fellowship in the Theoretical Nanophysics group at the Ludwig Maximilian University, Munich, from January 2013.

In Part 1 of this post he discusses the foundations of the field of atomic, molecular, and optical physics, and describes the process of laser cooling, an experimental technique for cooling atoms to extremely low temperatures. This technique forms the foundation for many of the current experiments in the field.

In Part 2 of this post he describes the experiments carried out by Haroche and Wineland, and discusses the possible applications and future directions of their work.]



2012 Nobel Laureates in Physics Serge Haroche (left) and David J. Wineland (photo credit: CNRS, NIST).

The 2012 Nobel Prize in Physics: score one more for AMO physics

Those with their finger on the physics pulse will have seen that the 2012 Nobel Prize in Physics was recently awarded jointly to Serge Haroche and David J. Wineland for their development of "ground-breaking experimental methods that enable measuring and manipulation of individual quantum systems". This announcement raises a number of questions for physicists and physics followers alike: what is meant by an ‘individual quantum system’, and why would anyone want to measure and manipulate such a thing? What kind of experiments do Haroche and Wineland do, and what new scientific and technological possibilities does their research unlock? And -- last but not least -- will Prof. Wineland be involved in the imminent month of Movember? Because if he is, everyone else might as well just go home right now.


Atomic, molecular, and optical physics: a brief history

The research of Haroche and Wineland falls within the field of atomic, molecular, and optical (AMO) physics, which studies how particles of matter (atoms, ions, and molecules) interact both with one another and with particles of light (photons: see figure), and how these interactions can be controlled and exploited to engineer systems of particular scientific or technological interest. AMO physics is currently a highly active and dynamic area of research, with applications which range from questions of fundamental scientific interest (e.g. is it possible that the fine structure constant is actually changing slowly with time?) through to real-world technologies (e.g. the development of ultra-precise atomic clocks for the definition of universal time and frequency standards). It has also enjoyed somewhat of a Golden Age in recent years, with the 2012 Nobel Prize in Physics being the third in the last 15 years (after 1997 and 2001) to be awarded for work in the field.

The physical theory that governs the world in the ultra-small regime of atoms, molecules, and photons is the theory of quantum mechanics, which describes both the behavior of these individual quantum systems and the way in which they interact. The roots of AMO physics can thus be traced back to the early part of the 20th century, when quantum mechanics was developed in the course of the search for a better understanding of such phenomena as the radiation emitted by hot objects and the internal structure of atoms.


A rough sketch of an atom (not actual size).    
The electrons orbiting the nucleus are only 
permitted to occupy a certain discrete set of 
energy levels.

Building on the theory of quantum mechanics, the state of atomic physics improved at a breathtaking pace throughout the first half of the 20th century. In contrast, research into the ‘optical’ part of AMO physics progressed at a more sedate pace. While much of the required theoretical knowledge already existed – the wave theory of light and the electronic structure of atoms both being well-understood by this point – rapid progress in any field requires interaction between theory and experiment, and the absence of any technology that could produce a focused, powerful, and wavelength-specific (i.e. single-colour) source of light severely restricted the sophistication of possible atom-light experiments.

This state of affairs changed drastically with the invention of the laser in the early 1960s. Developing out of radar and microwave research carried out during the Second World War at Bell Laboratories, lasers provided a light that was radically different from anything seen before: in addition to containing only a single pure wavelength, laser light is well collimated (i.e. forms a well-defined beam) and can easily be millions of times more intense than any other light source. At a stroke, the door was opened to a whole range of possible new atom-light experiments, ushering in a new era in the discipline of atomic, molecular and optical physics.




Laser light can be viewed as either a travelling electromagnetic wave (left) or a stream of photons (right).











Laser cooling: the beginning of the Golden Age

One particularly striking demonstration of the possibilities that laser light provides for controlling and manipulating atoms has been the development of laser cooling: using tightly-focused beams of laser light to slow down, or cool, a collection of atoms in a gas. Developed throughout the 1980s and recognized with the 1997 Nobel Prize in Physics, laser cooling is today ubiquitous in a wide range of AMO physics experiments, and forms the foundation for the fertile subfield of ultracold atoms.

But you thought lasers could only heat things up, or burn holes in them? Then read on. 

The atoms in a gas at room temperature move about very rapidly (their speed depends on the temperature of the gas, but in any case is of the order of several hundred metres per second). Now imagine that you’re an experimental physicist, and your goal is to manipulate and interact with these atoms in some kind of precise, controlled way -- for example, you might want to carry out some spectroscopy on them in order to measure the exact frequencies of light that this atomic species absorbs and emits. In this case, working with a ‘hot’ gas of rapidly-moving atoms is far from ideal -- in fact, it’s a complete disaster. Since the atoms are moving reasonably quickly, the radiation they absorb and emit is subject to a significant Doppler shift, making precise frequency measurements impossible. Further, the atoms collide both with one another and with the walls of their container, and these collisions lead to an additional ‘smearing out’ of the frequencies emitted or absorbed by each atom.

These problems could be largely nullified if only the atoms in the gas could be slowed down, or even brought to a complete stop. The great discovery of the 1980s and early 1990s was that this can be achieved by using laser light of a carefully-selected frequency to manipulate the atoms in the gas. Like many of the best achievements in science, the basic idea is both simple and elegant: a rapidly-moving atom is gradually slowed down by bouncing a stream of photons off it, one after another. Although each photon takes only a small amount of momentum away from the atom, the absorption and re-emission of a photon takes place in less than a microsecond, so that a single atom can scatter over a million photons every second. Consequently, an atom can be slowed down from a speed of several hundred metres per second (corresponding to room temperature) to a near-complete standstill in only a few thousandths of a second. These laser-cooled atoms -- which are at a far lower temperature than anything found in nature, even in the deepest depths of outer space -- can now be measured, probed, and further manipulated with an extremely high degree of accuracy.




The process of laser cooling: by arranging a set of lasers such that they remove momentum from the rapidly-moving atoms in a room-temperature gas, clouds of up to a few tens of millions of atoms can be cooled down to temperatures of less than a millionth of a degree above absolute zero .

[If you'd like to try out laser-cooling for yourself, the University of Colorado at Boulder has made a fantastic series of interactive Java applets that describe the process very well.]

Together with the invention of related techniques for trapping clouds of laser-cooled atoms using combinations of laser light and magnetic fields, the development of laser cooling stimulated a frenzy of new activity in atomic, molecular, and optical physics. Since the early 1990s, the level of experimental control in cold-atom experiments has progressed to the point where it is now routine to isolate, trap, and cool either individual atoms, or clouds of up to a few tens of millions of atoms, to temperatures of a few hundreds of nanoKelvin (billionths of a degree above absolute zero) in a controlled and repeatable fashion.  These new experimental capabilities have found applications in a diverse range of topics, which span all facets of atomic, molecular, and optical physics. Two such topics in which laser cooling plays an integral role – namely, the interaction of laser-cooled atoms with light trapped between two very small mirrors, and the interaction of light with laser-cooled ions trapped by rapidly-oscillating electric fields – are those in which the Nobel-winning research of Serge Haroche and David Wineland lies.

[Part 2, coming soon...]

Monday, October 22, 2012

The human machine: communication technologies


The previous post in this series can be found here.

Have you ever stopped to consider what makes you a single organism? It might sound strange, but it is a question dripping in biological significance. You may think of yourself as a neatly packaged single unit, yet you are probably also aware that this one unit is made up of tiny individual cells working together. But how do 75,000,000,000,000-odd cells cooperate with such precision? Why your cells work together is entirely separate question with answers to do with filling evolutionary niches and delegating functional roles; I'm talking about how they do it. That's the million dollar question! 

Well, to be precise, it's the $1.2 million (or 8 million Swedish Krona) question, as it was announced last week that this year's Nobel Prize in Chemistry (and the accompanying monetary reward) has been awarded to Robert Lefkowitz and Brian Kobilka for their outstanding work into the biology of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs). In this post I hope to give you an understanding of how GPCRs work, why they're important enough to deserve a Nobel Prize, and how they relate the question of how you stay as just one you.


GPCRs - the eyes and ears of the cell 

If you were a cell, how would you know what to do? When should you divide, where should you move, what should you make? You couldn't just do it randomly or to some pre-determined schedule because the human you're in is unpredictable and its cells must be flexible in their behaviour to match that. So, what you really need to make these decisions is information. This is exactly the same as how humans make decisions about our behaviour, we gather information about the surrounding environment through our senses and then act appropriately. A cell that receives no information from outside its own membrane is as impotent as a human with no sense of sight, smell, touch, taste or hearing. Ok, so they need information, how do they get it? As you've probably guessed given my snappy subtitle and general build-up, the answer is receptors!

Wednesday, July 4, 2012

A Higgs Hunter's story...

[Note from Shaun: Here is Higgs hunter Mikko Voutilainen's account of the recent search for the Higgs. You can find the teaser to this post here. And my own, partially cynical, but ultimately upbeat, account of Higgs-things, here.]

Here it is, finally

[I assume the readers of this blog are somewhat familiar with the Higgs boson; if not, there's a nice summary on the CMS pages here]

So, this is the follow-up to the teaser I wrote a week ago. Now that everybody knows we found a Higgs boson at \(125.3\pm 0.6\) GeV, I'm free to talk about our finding, what it means and how we got there. Note the intentional use of 'a' Higgs there: although we, beyond reasonable doubt (less than one in a million chance of an error, to be precise), found a new particle, it's not 100% sure yet if it's *the* Higgs boson predicted by the standard model, or one of its many twins predicted by the hundreds of theories out there. There's even a tiny chance of it being an altogether different particle yet.

We actually already know a fair deal about this new particle besides the rather impressively precise estimate of its mass: it seems to be produced at a rate that matches the standard model prediction within about 20% uncertainty, it decays into bosons (W, Z and photon) and fermions (b-quarks and tau-leptons) roughly in the ratios predicted by the standard model, and in particular it decays into W and Z bosons in the ratio predicted by the standard model. The last point is rather important, because the Higgs mechanism, and the Higgs boson along with it, was invented to give mass to the W and Z bosons, and leave the photon massless. This also fixes the ratio of the decay rates to W and Z. If the new particle didn't decay into Z's and W's in just the right ratio, it couldn't be the Higgs boson we predicted.

We've also had a stab at determining the more abstract properties of the particle such as a quantum number called parity, but the statistics are low and the results still inconclusive. Predictions say we should be able to tell by the end of the current run, when we've collected 2--3 times the amount of data we have now. At this point we should also have more precise determination of the particle's decay rates in all the different channels, in order to gain more confidence in calling the particle a Higgs boson or something else.

So, is this the end, or the beginning of something new? I'm really hoping for the latter. If the new particle turns out to be 'just' the standard model Higgs boson and there's nothing new to be found, that would be fairly boring. If instead it's a Higgs twin, we may have just opened a window into a new landscape of particles.

At the moment it's too early to tell for sure, but there are a few interesting features to the way the new particle decays. It seems to decay into photons more often than expected, and to tau-leptons less often than expected. Taking all the decays to fermions together, they only seem to add up to about half of the rate predicted by the standard model, albeit with an error of about 50% as well. That coincidence is causing a bit of excitement nevertheless.

It might not be too bad for the standard model, though, it could just indicate that it's 'non-minimal'. While the Higgs coupling to W and Z is pretty tightly constrained, all the other particle masses are more of an ad-hoc addition to the theory, and there's some freedom to adjust how these particles couple to the Higgs boson without breaking everything else. Another good example of something that would require a 'non-minimal' standard model are the neutrino masses, which in the simplest expectation are exactly zero. We now know they are not zero, although we've still to nail down exactly how much they weigh (it's very very little in any case).

What for me was most interesting in this was to see first-hand how things have evolved towards a big discovery. Things started rolling about six months ago, when the first results from LHC Higgs boson searches were presented last December. Back then both ATLAS and CMS saw a hint of a Higgs at 125 GeV, with about 2-2.5 sigma statistical confidence. If you were a Higgs-believer, you could have given the signal more than 95% chance of being true.

After December it was decided that we wouldn't look at the 2012 data in the signal region before we had enough to confirm or refute the hint seen in 2011. This process is called blinding, and its important for making sure the analyzers are not unconciously affected by their prior expectations. Blinding is also one of the reasons we've tried to keep a lid on the results until today's seminar so that the experiments would not affect each other's findings between opening their signal box opening and presenting the final results. I think we were fairly successful in the end, although rumors started circulating on the blogs within days, and by yesterday almost every major newspaper (including Nature) had run a story on Higgs.

Between opening the signal box and seeing the first evidence of a new particle there was a whole lot of work going on for 2--3 weeks to prepare for ICHEP. The analyses added around 50% more data, the particle properties were studied in more detail, the CMS management had regular meetings with both ATLAS and CERN directors, people were working day and night to scrutinize the results, prepare documentation, etc. The final days were spent polishing plots, rehearsing presentations and fine-tuning press releases. Although I didn't happen to be at CERN during that period (I did attend the signal box opening in the beginning, though), I could at least participate through the almost daily video meetings and by keeping my own small piece of CMS running (I'm responsible for a team calibrating jets).

Just two days prior to the seminar there was also a presentation of the Tevatron Higgs results at Fermilab. The Tevatron people had done a superb job in squeezing every last bit of sensitivity out of their data and fell just a hair's width short of claiming evidence for the Higgs (they got 2.94 sigma by the most optimistic count, and needed 3.0). The Tevatron experiments collected data for ten years before shutting down last summer, and have the same amount of data (10 fb-1) available for analysis as the LHC experiments now. The lower collision energy of the Tevatron, 2 TeV versus 8 TeV at LHC, means roughly ten times less Higgs bosons are produced, but they still have better sensitivity in one single channel, the Higgs decaying into two b-quarks. I was watching that live on video, too, cheering for my old colleagues (I did my PhD on D0, one of the two experiments at the Tevatron).

And then, finally, today we had a chance to see how our colleagues and rivals at ATLAS were doing with their Higgs search. According to blog rumors, newspaper leaks and sensitivity estimate just a tad behind CMS, but never far. As it turned out, both CMS and ATLAS came up with the same significance in the end, within 0.1 sigma precision. Both experiments have now just made it to the 5-sigma milestone, and it's pretty clear that the signal has been effectively confirmed by at least three experiments (counting D0 and CDF together as a single Tevatron experiment).

P.S. I wrote a lengthy story about the box opening the same evening when I was at CERN, and stored it on a time capsule on my e-mail account. I'm not sure if it's interesting anymore, but at least I shouldn't be breaking any confidentiality rules by releasing it. [Shaun speaking: I now have this item in my possession, so if anyone wants to see it please let me know and I will upload it in a few days.]

Tuesday, October 4, 2011

Congratulations Cosmology

The news today had an almost poetic structure to it, as if it was part of a well crafted story.

Firstly, for all those rock dwellers out there, the Nobel Prize in physics, announced today, went to two groups who, in 1998, turned the world of cosmology upside down. Their discovery subsequently planted a great big question mark in the rest of the world of fundamental physics, for it was the observations made by today's Nobel prize winners that caused the entry into the standard cosmological model of that most mysterious of concepts:
Dark Energy
The observation these groups made is all the more beautiful for how mundane it actually is. They simply made the observation that a bunch of distant supernovae were dimmer than had previously been expected. But, still today, nobody has any good idea what causes this dimming. Subsequent cosmological observations have made it clear that the dimness of these supernovae probably means the expansion of the universe is accelerating, but why? And if it isn't accelerating, what profound property of our universe is so cleverly mimicking this acceleration.

This was great news for cosmology and if the fact that observations of exploding stars can completely change our understanding of the make up of the universe wasn't poetic enough, today also happened to be the day that ESA announced its next wave of big experiments. One of these was Euclid (artist's impression below). The confirmation of Euclid's eventual launch is also great news for cosmology. On the same day that one beautiful cosmological experiment wins the most prestigious prize available to a scientist, another beautiful cosmological experiment is announced.

What is ESA's stated goal for Euclid? Nothing else but:
To understand the nature of dark energy and dark matter by accurate measurement of the accelerated expansion of the Universe through different independent methods.
And so, while today the big news headlines were of the Nobel Prize being awarded to the two groups who pointed out an enormous cosmological mystery, it is not outside the realm of possibility that hiding subtly in the news background the experiment that will solve this mystery was also today finally made a certainty.

You couldn't write a better script if you tried.

An artist's impression of the Euclid satellite